|
Interview to Raewyn Connell. Connell holds a University Chair in the University of Sydney and is a member of the Australian Academy of Science. Connell is best known outside Australia for studies of the social construction of masculinity: “Biological difference is biological difference; it is not social fate.”

It seems like there have always been different roll assignments for men and women throughout the different historical moments and cultures. But what does it mean to “be a man” in the Western culture nowadays? What has changed?
We should not exaggerate gender division in the past. Women and men have usually worked together cooperatively – peasant farms would not work, otherwise! And often women and men do the same tasks. We have, after all, very similar capabilities. Men can plant rice, do child-care and nurse the sick; women can dig coal, run laboratories and build computers.
Nevertheless most societies have drawn symbolic distinctions between women and men. Most societies have gendered ownership and power arrangements, and have a gender division of labour. This is usually explained by our reproductive differences. There is a lot of myth-making here, and we need some robust common sense. Biological difference is biological difference; it is not social fate. Its significance beyond the business of reproduction is exaggerated by mass media, pop psychologists and religious leaders alike.
So we have to be careful in thinking about what it is to “be a man”. There isn’t just one story. There is abundant evidence in modern research that there are multiple patterns of masculinity in modern societies – different patterns of practice, different “identities”, different positions in gender relations.
We can certainly point to some widespread (though not universal) changes. With the spread of industrial and commercial capitalism, more and more productive work moved outside households, and the idea of a “breadwinner” was born. This identity is now under threat around the world, because very large numbers of working-class men don’t have reliable jobs to go to. Precarious labour is now the life of great numbers of young men.
Among bourgeois men, being an owner, husband and father used to be tied together with religion – their authority was God’s will. For a significant number, this implied a certain responsibility for their workers. With the decline of religion this becomes less credible, and transnational corporate management is now almost completely Godless. The idea of responsibility for workers is dead. Welcome to neoliberalism!
Last year you took part in the First Ibero-American Congress for the Masculinity and Equity in Barcelona. What would you highlight from what you saw, listened and experienced? Could you find any common elements with what is happening in Australia or other places in Asia where your research is based?
The Ibero-American Congress on Masculinity and Equity was very encouraging to me. First, because of the name! It meant that people in Spain (and Latin America) are thinking about the problems of masculinity in terms of what they can do towards justice. In other places I have heard a lot of moaning about the supposed crisis of masculinity or the sufferings of men at the hands of feminism. This Congress was a breath of fresh air, a positive direction.
I only speak three words of Spanish, and none of Catalan (or Basque), so although I listened hard, my understanding was very imperfect. What interested me most was the way the Congress served as a forum for activist groups, to meet and consider political directions. It’s important to see that being done in an open forum.
I am impressed by the Declaration adopted at the end of the Congress, and I have been circulating this to other people. There are activist groups of men in many other parts of the world, many working in an NGO context; but this kind of event is rare.
Do you think it is possible or necessary to create a Men´s Movement for Equality?
Men are, by and large, the privileged group in gender relations – in terms of income and wealth, organizational power (including politics), cultural authority (including religion), access to space, personal services from women, and so on. We can measure this privilege empirically; I call it the “patriarchal dividend”. Lots of men do not get much of this privilege, and some are marginalized by patriarchal gender relations – gay men, for instance. Broadly, however, men benefit from patriarchy, and we cannot expect a privileged group to rise up with banners and overthrow the system!
But a lot of men can see through this privilege, and realize the damage it does to the women and girls who matter to them, and to the human relationships in their own lives. Many men can see that privilege is inconsistent with the principles they believe in, such as equality and justice. Men may also see – in trade unions for instance – that the oppression of women weakens their shared struggle.
So there are significant groups of men willing to act for gender justice. Organization is needed, to turn that willingness into a social force. Whether we call it a “men’s movement” or not, does not matter very much. What matters is doing things in practice. Often men will be acting together with women; often the struggle will be through an organization that isn’t primarily organized on gender lines, such as a union or a cultural group. Men are very diverse, and there are a lot of fronts in the struggle for gender justice.
What kind of relationship should exist between a Men´s Movement for Equality and the Feminist Movement?
I don’t think there is a single formula for the relationship between men and women in the pursuit of gender justice. Of course the main energy for change in the gender order will come from women; but the women’s movement too is very diverse. In some areas, such as work concerning domestic violence, rape, and femicide, it’s very difficult for men and women to work together, the horror and violence make that tough. Yet some degree of cooperation is necessary, and it’s often achieved in practice. In other areas, cooperation has been going on for a long time, e.g. equal opportunity and anti-discrimination work in governments and workplaces. We have a lot of experience to build on. My advice to men is always to try, rather than to hesitate because they might offend someone. It’s better to get oppressive gender relations shaken up, challenged, from any direction, than to leave things as they are.
Your work has reflected deeply on the different hegemonic masculine patterns. What could you tell us about the health of the alternative patterns of anti-hegemonic masculinity or masculinities?
That’s a very complicated question. (If you ask an academic, you can expect to get that answer!)
Some subordinated masculinities find a more secure place in the world. I think that is mostly true for gay masculinities in Australia, and probably in much of Europe. De-criminalization helps, equal rights and anti-discrimination laws help, and police practices seem to have changed. These changes don’t prevent anti-gay violence, including quite horrific murders, from time to time.
Some marginalized masculinities are under much more pressure. Where there is a combination of unemployment, a widespread drug traffic, and perhaps ethnic minority status, young men’s lives are at risk, and levels of violence towards women as well as men may be high. From a distance, it looks as if something like that is happening among immigrant groups in Europe, but you would know better than I.
The masculinities that are constructed in conscious opposition to hegemonic masculinity are less visible and harder to track. My own research with men in the Green movement, back in the 1980s, and some US research about the same time, suggested that such oppositional masculinities were hard to build and sustain, given all the cultural pressures in the other direction. On the other hand, the wide popularity of “Zivildienst” as alternative to military service in Germany suggests quite a broad shift of attitudes. And there is no doubt that there has been a long-term shift in attitudes, in many countries, in favour of gender equality.
Perhaps we can’t tell what is the “health” of alternatives to hegemonic masculinity. What we definitely can say, is that alternatives keep bubbling up. Diverse groups of men, especially young men, keep trying to build new gender practices, gender-equal households and peaceable relations with women. And that is grounds for hope.
In this world of crisis within which we live, do you think that the fight for equality has also entered a crisis? Could the fight for equality also fall into a recession?
I would say the fight for equality is always in crisis. And I don’t think it is any harder in a recession or easier in a boom. Yes, there is an ebb and flow in struggles for gender equality. There are backlashes, even catastrophes for women – fascism was one. The toxic gender ideology of the Wahhabi sect (now enormously influential in the Muslim world because backed by Saudi oil wealth, in turn backed by the USA) is another. The Pope is not only the head of an intransigent global patriarchy but has declared hostility to the very concept of gender! Narcotrafico, and the very violent masculinities that flourish with it, is another contemporary disaster for women. (I don’t want to blame the USA for everything, but this one is directly due to the combination of US wealth and hypocrisy, preventing global harm reduction.)
But there are also remarkable gains. Whenever I feel despairing, I pull out the statistics of literacy. Over the last two generations, there has been a huge gain in literacy for women worldwide, and for the education of girls. It’s a historic triumph (which many men as well as women helped to bring about), and all sorts of consequences, economic, cultural, and political, are flowing from it. Sometimes I think what the Pope and the Ayatollah are really about is trying to turn back the tide of women’s education.
Violence against women is one of the most worrying consequences of sexism. More recently in Spain, there has been an increase in the number of cases of younger men who use violence against women. Are classical, patriarchal patterns being repeated, taking on a more sophisticated and modern appearance?
New patterns of violence against women are found in other places too. You will have heard about the femicide in Ciudad Juárez. Central Africa is the site of widespread rape in the context of complex civil wars. The Internet has become a site of very widespread sexism, though it’s hard to tell how much is translated into practice. The HIV/AIDS epidemic is now mainly “heterosexual” and the virus spreads widely in contexts of men’s dominance and coercion towards women.
But this isn’t “traditional” masculinity. There is research in Africa, especially, that suggests this violence is more about the breakdown of old gender orders - under the pressures of colonialism, war, poverty, urbanization, capitalism and neoliberal power. Violence has many causes, but it’s a likely hypothesis that gender violence is increasingly driven by attempts to restore or re-make masculine power in new circumstances.
Certainly some of the pop psychology that circulates as wisdom about gender relations (Men are from Mars, etc.) has a strongly nostalgic tone, and urges men to return to their roots, find the deep masculine, restore fatherhood, etc. etc. But most of this is fantasy. If some of the voices urging a return to true classical masculinity were actually sent by time machine to live in a pre-industrial village, they would get a nasty shock.
What importance and role does neoliberal globalisation have and play in the construction of the contemporary masculinities, as you suggest in your book “Masculinities”?
Neoliberal globalization is the main economic frame of our time. Europe is going through a painful demonstration of that right now. Market ideology and managerial dominance has effects in every sphere of life – schools, family life, workplaces, mass media, universities, and so on. There is inevitably an impact on the making of masculinities.
But it isn’t just in one direction. Neoliberalism increases class divisions, and its impact in the lives of ruling-class men is different from the lives of working-class men. Ruling-class men get more wealth and power, not less; their collective strategies are successful. There is no agenda of masculinity reform in the boardrooms of transnational corporations. They exploit gender divisions among consumers and in the workforce, as they exploit differences in standards of living – look at the maquilas, or the microprocessor assembly plants in China or South-East Asia. Men of the global corporate elite generally have dependent wives, privatised health care and education, and live their lives physically cocooned from the working class.
The story is different for men from the popular classes. Economic restructuring, the decline of welfare states, the corporatisation of agriculture, migration, life in favelas, the growth of “security” industries, precarious employment in service industries – all these are part of the picture. I have always emphasised that there is not just one masculinity, and there is not just one trajectory for men. That’s still the case.
Are you an optimist or a pessimist when you refer to the present and the future of equal relationships?
I’m an optimist. When I think about the lives of many young people I know, I’m impressed at the ease with which they handle equality in sexual and domestic relationships - issues with which my generation struggled endlessly. I admire the many movements, groups and campaigns that spring up around the world, among men as well as among women, to change oppressive systems.
I’m also a realist. I know that changing entrenched privilege and great concentrations of power is hard to do. Confronting violence is very difficult. Change is uneven, and sometimes we go backwards, as I’ve mentioned.
But sometimes we do go forward, and looking over the last forty years that I have been involved in social struggles, I think some remarkable changes for the good have happened. In countries like mine, and I think yours too, the cultural presumption is now in favour of gender equality, though formerly it was in favour of patriarchy. It has taken a lot of work, a lot of struggle, and it’s not fireproof; but there has been a deep change already. It’s up to us to keep it going.
|